Yes No Share to Facebook
Roadway Includes Signage: Involves the Interpretation of Signage As Roadway Infrastructure
Question: Does the legal definition of “roadway” in Ontario include traffic signs for municipal maintenance and liability purposes?
Answer: In Ontario municipal law, a “highway” or “roadway” can be interpreted to include more than the paved surface, extending to infrastructure like sidewalks, boulevards, ditches, and signage, and courts have treated missing or poorly maintained required signs as part of a municipality’s road-repair obligations (see The Queen v. Jennings et al., [1966] S.C.R. 532). For Ontario-specific next steps, a Legal Profession Ecosystem service can help you organize facts, preserve evidence, and connect with properly licensed legal professionals for advice on your situation.
Understanding That the Definition of Roadway Includes Signage
When involved in litigation that requires a legal interpretation of the term "highway", which is synonymous to the word "roadway" in the context of municipal law, it is necessary to broadly review the terms used within the Municipal Act, 2001, S.O. 2001, Chapter 25, as well as to review precedent case decisions . Upon review of what constitutes as the "roadway", much more than just the roadway surface is deemed included whereas prior decisions confirm that a sidewalk, a boulevard, a ditch, and other portions of the roadway infrastructure form the overall "roadway". Among the overall infrastructure forming the "roadway" is signage. Although a case decision arising prior to the enactment of the current Municipal Act, 2001, the case of The Queen v. Jennings et al., [1966] S.C.R. 532, provides instruction on the interpretation of signage as an element of the "roadway" requiring maintenance by a municipality. Specifically, within the Jennings case it was said:
The appellant contends that failure to maintain a stop sign as required by the relevant statute and regulations does not amount to “default to keep the King’s Highway in repair”. In the Courts below this submission has been unanimously rejected and, in my opinion, rightly so. It has been repeatedly held in Ontario that where a duty to keep a highway in repair is imposed by statute the body upon which it is imposed must keep the highway in such a condition that travellers using it with ordinary care may do so with safety. The danger created by the failure to maintain the required stop signs marking a through highway is too obvious to require comment.
Conclusion
The term "highway" under the Municipal Act, 2001, which also includes the term "roadway", involves elements of the roadway beyond just roadway surfaces and includes boulevards, sidewalks, ditches, and signage; and accordingly, a municipality may be liable for injury or damage that arises from a failure to maintain signs.